We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Good American jeans →GOOD PETITE STRAIGHT JEANS | INDIGO511
The verdict
Fit
The cut is narrow with a mid-rise, and it runs roughly true but stretches a lot in wear; one petite reviewer swapped from a 00 to a 0 because the smaller size felt snug at hips and waist. The petite length still ran about half an inch long for her, so shorter shoppers may need a hem.
Quality
The denim is soft with a lot of stretch and, per the reviewer, shrinks back in the wash after loosening during wear. The brand's gap-proof waistband held with no back gapping across styles testers tried.
Is the price fair?
At $169 it is a premium buy for the category; brand testing found the gap-proof waistband and stretch worth the price, though the amount of give is more than some shoppers want in a straight jean.
Best for
A petite shopper who wants a soft, narrow mid-rise straight with a secure, non-gapping waist and is comfortable with plenty of stretch.
Care
Wash cold and avoid over-drying; the denim tends to shrink back after a wash, which helps it recover from daily stretching.
Grounded in reviewer & owner reports: Good American vs Madewell Jeans: An Honest Petite Review · Good American Jeans review: Are they worth the price tag — and the hype?
Fit check: Good American
Varies by lineOwners say the denim fits true to size despite looking tiny off the body, while the sweats and outerwear are cut oversized.
Across independent reviews the denim story is consistent: the jeans look alarmingly small off the body but stretch to fit true to size once on — one long-form reviewer's advice is to "order your true size rather than sizing down." The recurring caveat is Good American's combined size bands (e.g. 6-12): a Yahoo tester at the top of her band found the Always Fits pair "snug, especially through the hips and thighs," and reviewers who sit between sizes report some styles running slightly small. The sweats line reads the opposite way — pieces are deliberately roomy, with "extra fabric in the arms to create an oversized vibe," and owners size down when they want a closer fit. Fit reports on jackets and the shacket are mixed, so per-style checks matter most outside the denim.
Sizing advice: Take your usual size in the jeans even though they look tiny off the body (size up only if you're at the top of a combined size band); in the sweats, size down for anything other than an oversized fit.
Per owner & reviewer reports: Good American Jeans Review: Do They Run Small + Are They … · Good American Jeans Review — Honest Brand Reviews · Good American Jeans review — Yahoo Shopping · Good American Sweats, Essentials & A Really Great Shacket…
What owners report about Good American jeans
Owners report heavy stretch with strong recovery, and the gap-proof waistband claim largely holds up — one tester found no back gapping across three different pairs. The combined sizing, where one size covers several standard sizes, works for people in the middle of a band but runs snug or loose for those at the edges. A minority of owners report the opposite stretch problem: pairs that bag out and sag after only brief wear, and reviewers agree sizing is not consistent from style to style.
- Strengths
- Reviewers consistently report strong stretch and recovery and a waistband that avoids back gapping on curvier builds.
- Watch out for
- Sizing is inconsistent across styles and the combined size bands work poorly at their edges, while a minority of owners report pairs stretching out and sagging after minimal wear.
- Sizing
- Pairs look very small off the body but reviewers report they fit true to size once on; wearers at the top of a combined size band tend to find them tight, and ordering two sizes to compare is a common recommendation.
About Good American's jeans line as a whole. Sources: Good American Jeans review: Are they worth the price tag — and the hype? · My Honest Good American Jeans Review - MY CHIC OBSESSION · Good American Jeans Review: Do They Run Small + Are They Worth It? | Elisabeth McKnight
