We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Faherty sweaters →Donegal Crew Sweater - Walnut Feeder Marl
The verdict
Fit
Donegal knits are sturdy and hold their fit well through wear. Crew cuts fit snug; size up if you like breathing room.
Quality
Merino wool blends at this price point are robust—wrinkle-resistant, breathable, and durable across years of wear.
Is the price fair?
At USD 84, this is the entry point for Faherty's wool-blend sweaters and represents genuine value for merino construction.
Best for
A man seeking an affordable wool sweater that performs in layering and improves with age, without premium-tier pricing.
Care
Hand wash in cold water or delicate cycle; dry flat to prevent stretching and maintain the nubby Donegal texture.
Fit check: Faherty
True to sizeFaherty fits true to size with a deliberately relaxed cut — take your usual size, and only size down on the roomiest dresses and boxy tees if you're between sizes.
Owners and hands-on reviewers consistently report Faherty running true to size, with the slight ease built into the cut rather than a sign to size down. The relaxed silhouette shows up across lines — tees are described as boxy-but-not-oversized, pants run about a half-inch generous in the waist (not enough to change size), and some dresses and boxier tops read roomy enough that between-sizes buyers go down. A minority of owners find pieces large and boxy at their usual size — one Reddit user had a medium tailored — and a few customer reviews flag garment-to-garment inconsistency, but that's the exception in the feedback, not the pattern.
Sizing advice: Order your usual size across the line; if you're between sizes, size down only on roomy dresses and boxy tees — everywhere else stay true, since the relaxed drape is intentional.
Per owner & reviewer reports: Faherty Brand Review — An Indigo Day · Faherty Clothing Review — Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review — Honest Brand Reviews
What owners report about Faherty sweaters
Reviewers single out Faherty's sweater-knit fabrics for softness — one calls the brand's signature knit "probably the softest thing I own" — and report that pieces hold up with wear rather than degrading. Fit feedback is mixed: coverage describes a true-to-size, slightly relaxed cut, but at least one owner found a knit large and boxy for a normal medium and had it tailored. Price is the most consistent objection, with reviewers calling it high and noting the value case depends on wearing pieces for years.
- Strengths
- Notably soft sweater-knit fabrics that owners report hold up well to regular wear.
- Watch out for
- High prices and a relaxed cut that some owners find large and boxy are the recurring complaints.
- Sizing
- Reports point to a true-to-size but slightly relaxed cut; some owners find knits large and boxy in their usual size.
About Faherty's sweaters line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying · Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium?
