We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Faherty sweaters →Donegal Crew Sweater - Sea Feeder Marl
The verdict
Fit
Donegal wools have a characteristic nubby texture and typically run true to size. Crew cuts sit snug; size up for more room.
Quality
Merino wool blend at Faherty's USD 89 tier offers better wrinkle resistance and durability than cotton—holds up well over many seasons.
Is the price fair?
USD 89 is excellent value for a merino-blended sweater. The fiber quality easily justifies the price versus pure cotton at similar cost.
Best for
A man who wants a functional sweater that resists wrinkles and holds its shape, ideal for travel and layering through seasons.
Care
Hand wash or delicate cycle in cold water; lay flat to dry and avoid hanging, which can stretch wool fibers.
Fit check: Faherty
True to sizeFaherty fits true to size with a deliberately relaxed cut — take your usual size, and only size down on the roomiest dresses and boxy tees if you're between sizes.
Owners and hands-on reviewers consistently report Faherty running true to size, with the slight ease built into the cut rather than a sign to size down. The relaxed silhouette shows up across lines — tees are described as boxy-but-not-oversized, pants run about a half-inch generous in the waist (not enough to change size), and some dresses and boxier tops read roomy enough that between-sizes buyers go down. A minority of owners find pieces large and boxy at their usual size — one Reddit user had a medium tailored — and a few customer reviews flag garment-to-garment inconsistency, but that's the exception in the feedback, not the pattern.
Sizing advice: Order your usual size across the line; if you're between sizes, size down only on roomy dresses and boxy tees — everywhere else stay true, since the relaxed drape is intentional.
Per owner & reviewer reports: Faherty Brand Review — An Indigo Day · Faherty Clothing Review — Style & Serum · Faherty Clothing Review — Honest Brand Reviews
What owners report about Faherty sweaters
Reviewers single out Faherty's sweater-knit fabrics for softness — one calls the brand's signature knit "probably the softest thing I own" — and report that pieces hold up with wear rather than degrading. Fit feedback is mixed: coverage describes a true-to-size, slightly relaxed cut, but at least one owner found a knit large and boxy for a normal medium and had it tailored. Price is the most consistent objection, with reviewers calling it high and noting the value case depends on wearing pieces for years.
- Strengths
- Notably soft sweater-knit fabrics that owners report hold up well to regular wear.
- Watch out for
- High prices and a relaxed cut that some owners find large and boxy are the recurring complaints.
- Sizing
- Reports point to a true-to-size but slightly relaxed cut; some owners find knits large and boxy in their usual size.
About Faherty's sweaters line as a whole. Sources: Faherty Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying · Faherty Clothing Review: Is this Brand Worth the Premium?
