We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all American Giant polos →Men's Premium Slub Polo - Tapenade
The verdict
Fit
Same American Giant basics-focused cut. The slub texture may feel slightly looser-woven; expect slightly more drape than a crisp pique.
Quality
Slub cotton is inherently durable because of its irregular twist; it resists pilling and softens beautifully over time. At 115 USD, the premium designation is accurate but modest.
Is the price fair?
115 USD for premium slub cotton is fair value. You're paying slightly more for texture and longevity, not brand inflation.
Best for
Buyers who want visible texture in a casual polo and prefer a less-formal, more-lived-in aesthetic.
Care
Slub cotton's textured weave is forgiving; avoid fabric softener to preserve the natural hand.
What owners report about American Giant polos
Menswear reviewers describe American Giant's polos as casual, tee-like takes on the polo, made in Los Angeles from cotton: one review of the slub version calls the fabric lightweight and breathable without being overly thin, with a body that falls below the belt line without running long. Blog coverage of the polos themselves reports no durability problems and calls the roughly $70 pricing fair for US-made construction. Brand-level customer reviews are less uniform: alongside a 4.4/5 Trustpilot average, recurring complaints cite pilling, fabric fading within a wash or two, and inconsistent quality between batches on other garments in the range.
- Strengths
- Reviewers rate the polos' US-made cotton construction and casual cut highly, with fabric described as breathable without being thin and length that sits right at the belt line.
- Watch out for
- Polo-specific complaints are scarce, but brand-level customer reviews repeatedly report pilling, fading after one or two washes, and batch-to-batch quality inconsistency, so quality can vary by production run.
- Sizing
- Reviewers describe the body length as falling below the belt line without proving overly long; sources report no consensus to size up or down.
About American Giant's polos line as a whole. Sources: The Thursday Buy: USA-Made Polo from American Giant — The Style Guide · American Giant Review — Effortless Gent · American Giant Reviews — Trustpilot