We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all 3sixteen button-ups →Western Overshirt ~ Black
The verdict
Fit
3sixteen overplants are oversized and meant to wear open; expect room in the chest and shoulders. Sleeve length may run long.
Quality
At this price, the construction should be solid and the fabric substantial enough to hold a shape when worn open.
Is the price fair?
At $185, this is priced reasonably for a name-brand Western overshirt but relies on confident styling to justify the cost.
Best for
Shoppers comfortable with Western-inspired styling who want a layer that doubles as workwear or casual outerwear.
Care
Wash inside-out in cool water to preserve color on the outer surface; air dry to prevent shrinkage.
What owners report about 3sixteen button-ups
3sixteen's button-up range is anchored by the Crosscut Flannel, which editorial coverage describes as a heavy, all-cotton Japanese fabric with a brushed interior, chainstitch run-offs, and enamel buttons that are expected to wear and chip over time. A three-year owner review of the indigo knit version reports the shirt stayed in heavy rotation but the elbows eventually wore through the outer layer and needed patching, with fading concentrated at the cuffs and other high-wear areas. The same reviewer describes the fit as slim and tailored, with slight give in the fabric that keeps it unrestrictive.
- Strengths
- Reviewers consistently point to the substantial Japanese flannel fabric and visible construction detail as the reason these shirts stay in rotation for years.
- Watch out for
- In long-term wear the elbows are the first failure point — one three-year review reports them wearing through and needing patches — and the enamel buttons are expected to crack and chip with use.
- Sizing
- The Crosscut Flannel fits on the slim, tailored side; a long-term reviewer advises taking your usual 3sixteen shirt size, noting the fabric's slight stretch gives some leeway.
About 3sixteen's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: [Worn] 3sixteen Indigo Knit Crosscut Flannel - Three Year Review - Withered Fig · 3sixteen Crosscut Flannels are Back for Fall - Heddels
