Old Navy vs American Eagle: which button-up to buy, and when
Both land in the budget tier: the Old Navy Everyday Shirt at $30, the American Eagle Everyday Oxford at $45, $15 apart. Here is how they stack up, head to head.
| Old Navy | American Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $30 | $45 |
| Material | Lightweight cotton or cotton-blend (oxford / poplin / flannel by season). | Soft cotton oxford, cotton-blend flannel, and lightweight poplin, sometimes with a touch of stretch for comfort in slimmer cuts. |
| Fit | Regular casual fit, true to size; runs slightly boxy. | Slim and classic fits with a shorter, untuck-friendly hem; the slim cut is trim through the chest and arms. |
| Quality | Budget — thin fabric, basic buttons, collar and cuffs wear within a year. | Acceptable seams and buttons for the price, with thinner cottons that soften quickly and can pill over time. Built for casual rotation rather than long service. |
| Best for | Casual everyday wear, layering, and cheap stocking-up. | Casual everyday and campus wear, layered over tees or worn open with jeans and chinos. |
| Care | Cold wash and tumble low; expect some shrink and fade over the first washes. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; flannels keep their nap better when dried on low heat. |
Two thin, casual budget button-ups $15 apart, both cycling through oxford, poplin, and flannel by season. Old Navy's Everyday Shirt is $30 in a slightly boxy regular fit; AE's Everyday Oxford is $44.95 with slim and classic cuts and a shorter untuck-friendly hem. Neither fabric is built past casual rotation.
- The case for Old Navy
- At $30 the Old Navy does the same casual layering job for less and is the cheaper stock-up shirt if a regular cut fits you.
- The case for American Eagle
- The AE offers a real fit range — trim slim or classic with an untuck-friendly hem and optional stretch in the slimmer cuts — where Old Navy only gives you slightly boxy regular.
VerdictThe pick
The fit is the whole decision here. If a boxy regular cut works on you, buy the Old Navy: the fabrics are comparably thin, both wear out on a casual-rotation timeline, and it is $15 less. Step up to the AE if you want the slim cut or the shorter hem for wearing untucked — a genuine difference Old Navy cannot match at any discount. Just buy it during one of AE's frequent sitewide sales, where most shirts land well under list.
This link may pay us when you click or buy, at no extra cost to you.