Old Navy vs American Eagle: which button-up wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the Old Navy Everyday Shirt at $30, the American Eagle American Eagle Everyday Oxford at $45, just $15 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Old Navy | American Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $30 | $45 |
| Material | Lightweight cotton or cotton-blend (oxford / poplin / flannel by season). | Soft cotton oxford, cotton-blend flannel, and lightweight poplin, sometimes with a touch of stretch for comfort in slimmer cuts. |
| Fit | Regular casual fit, true to size; runs slightly boxy. | Slim and classic fits with a shorter, untuck-friendly hem; the slim cut is trim through the chest and arms. |
| Quality | Budget — thin fabric, basic buttons, collar and cuffs wear within a year. | Acceptable seams and buttons for the price, with thinner cottons that soften quickly and can pill over time. Built for casual rotation rather than long service. |
| Best for | Casual everyday wear, layering, and cheap stocking-up. | Casual everyday and campus wear, layered over tees or worn open with jeans and chinos. |
| Care | Cold wash and tumble low; expect some shrink and fade over the first washes. | Machine wash cold and tumble dry low; flannels keep their nap better when dried on low heat. |
Two thin, casual budget button-ups $15 apart, both cycling through oxford, poplin, and flannel by season. Old Navy's Everyday Shirt is $30 in a slightly boxy regular fit; AE's Everyday Oxford is $44.95 with slim and classic cuts and a shorter untuck-friendly hem. Neither fabric is built past casual rotation.
- The case for Old Navy
- At $30 the Old Navy does the same casual layering job for less and is the cheaper stock-up shirt if a regular cut fits you.
- The case for American Eagle
- The AE offers a real fit range — trim slim or classic with an untuck-friendly hem and optional stretch in the slimmer cuts — where Old Navy only gives you slightly boxy regular.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
The fit is the whole decision here. If a boxy regular cut works on you, buy the Old Navy: the fabrics are comparably thin, both wear out on a casual-rotation timeline, and it is $15 less. Step up to the AE if you want the slim cut or the shorter hem for wearing untucked — a genuine difference Old Navy cannot match at any discount. Just buy it during one of AE's frequent sitewide sales, where most shirts land well under list.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.