Old Navy vs Gap: which sweater wins?
Both land in the budget tier — the Old Navy Cotton-Blend Crew Sweater at $35, the Gap Cotton Crewneck Sweater at $50, just $15 apart. Here's how they stack up, head to head.
| Old Navy | Gap | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35 | $50 |
| Material | Cotton/acrylic and cotton/poly blends, light-mid gauge. | Cotton or cotton blend, mid gauge; some lighter wool-blend styles. |
| Fit | Standard casual fit, true to size. | Relaxed-classic fit, true to size. |
| Quality | Budget — lightweight blends that pill and lose shape sooner than wool. | Budget-tier — easy-care cotton knit; pills and can lose shape over time at the price. |
| Best for | Low-cost everyday knits, a wide colour range, and filling out a wardrobe cheaply. | Cheap washable layering, a broad colour palette, and everyday basics on sale. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and tumble low; shave pilling as it appears. | Machine wash cold gentle and lay flat or tumble low; shave any pilling. |
Old Navy's Cotton-Blend Crew is $35 of light-to-mid-gauge cotton/acrylic and cotton/poly knits; Gap's Cotton Crewneck is $50 of mid-gauge cotton or cotton blend, with some lighter wool-blend styles in the line. Both pill and lose shape at this price — the $15 mostly buys higher cotton content and a slightly heavier gauge, not durability.
- The case for Old Navy
- $35 and often under $30 on promo; wide colour range for filling out a rotation cheaply; machine-washes the same; the right price for a knit you'll be shaving pills off either way.
- The case for Gap
- Mid-gauge, cotton-forward knit versus lighter acrylic and poly blends; some wool-blend styles available; relaxed-classic true-to-size fit; still fully machine-washable.
The bottom lineWhich should you buy?
Buy the Old Navy at $35 if you're stocking colours cheaply and expect to replace the knit rather than keep it — that's exactly how reviewers treat it. Step up to the Gap on sale if you want more cotton and a mid-gauge knit that reads less synthetic; at $50 list it's still budget-tier and still pills, so don't pay full price. Either way you're buying a washable basic, not a long-haul sweater — the $15 buys fiber content, not years.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.