Banana Republic vs Old Navy: is the pricier sweater worth it?
The Old Navy Cotton-Blend Crew Sweater runs $35; the Banana Republic Merino Crew Sweater is $90 — about 2.6× the price ($55 more). Here's the side-by-side, and what that gap actually buys.
| Old Navy | Banana Republic | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $35 | $90 |
| Material | Cotton/acrylic and cotton/poly blends, light-mid gauge. | Extra-fine merino wool (cotton-cashmere blends available), fine-mid gauge. |
| Fit | Standard casual fit, true to size. | Clean slightly-tailored fit, true to size. |
| Quality | Budget — lightweight blends that pill and lose shape sooner than wool. | Solid mid-tier — genuine merino, clean finishing; pills at friction points over time. |
| Best for | Low-cost everyday knits, a wide colour range, and filling out a wardrobe cheaply. | Office layering, smart-casual wear, and a clean tailored merino knit. |
| Care | Machine wash cold and tumble low; shave pilling as it appears. | Gentle wool cycle or hand-wash and lay flat; shave any pilling. |
A $35 cotton/acrylic crew against a $90 extra-fine merino one — this comparison is really synthetic blend versus actual wool. Old Navy sells colour variety and low cost; Banana Republic sells the fiber upgrade, with the caveat that even genuine fine merino pills at friction points.
- The case for Old Navy
- At $35 (often under $30 on promo) the Old Navy crew comes in a wide colour range, machine-washes without ceremony, and lets you fill out a knitwear rotation for the price of one merino sweater.
- The case for Banana Republic
- The BR Merino Crew is genuine extra-fine merino with clean finishing and a slightly-tailored fit, which means better drape and an office-appropriate look that light cotton/acrylic blends can't fake.
The bottom lineIs the pricier one worth it?
Buy the Old Navy if you want cheap seasonal colour and accept that the blend pills and loses shape sooner — it's wardrobe filler, and at this price that's a legitimate strategy. Step up to the Banana Republic if you layer knits over collars at work; real merino is the visible, wearable difference the $55 markup buys, and no amount of acrylic gets you there. Two honest caveats: the merino demands gentler washing, and it still pills at cuffs and elbows over time — so buy it on promo, where reviewers agree the value actually lands.
We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.