We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all Taylor Stitch polos →The Button Down Polo in Coal Herringbone
The verdict
Fit
Button-down polos add formality; expect fitted shoulders and a defined waist typical of this style. Herringbone adds visual texture without changing fit.
Quality
Herringbone weaves at this price are sturdy and reliable—typical of Taylor Stitch's mid-tier construction, no luxury refinement.
Is the price fair?
Fair value. The texture and button front justify the price over plain polos; solid mid-tier positioning.
Best for
Someone wanting a slightly more polished polo for casual or business-casual settings.
Care
Herringbone weaves are stable; standard warm water wash and medium heat dry work well.
What owners report about Taylor Stitch polos
Reviewers describe Taylor Stitch polos as tailored and on the slim side, with a collar that reviewers say holds its shape out of the bag and after repeated washing. Fit coverage is favorable for shorter and slimmer builds: one reviewer wearing an XS found the polo fit perfectly and called it more accommodating for shorter men than most brands. Broader Taylor Stitch feedback praises durable construction that holds up to wear, though some buyers report inconsistencies between sizes and measurements.
- Strengths
- Reviewers consistently praise the tailored fit, shape-retaining collar, and durable construction that holds up over time.
- Watch out for
- Some buyers report inconsistencies in sizes and measurements, so the fit is not always predictable across pieces.
- Sizing
- Reviewers describe the cut as true to size but slim, so those between sizes or wanting a looser fit may prefer to size up.
About Taylor Stitch's polos line as a whole. Sources: Taylor Stitch's Strapping Style & The Tie Bar's Fun Classics: A Review - The Modest Man · In-Depth Taylor Stitch Review (2026) - Is it worth it? · Taylor Stitch Clothing Review - Must Read This Before Buying · Taylor Stitch Review: I Tried Their Most Popular Styles