We may earn a commission if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.
Browse all James Perse button-ups →Herringbone Twill Shirt Jacket - Caribou Pigment
The verdict
Fit
Shirt jackets sit between shirt and jacket; James Perse's cut is roomy through the shoulders and body, meant to layer over t-shirts. Runs true to size.
Quality
Herringbone twill is durable and resists wrinkles better than plain weave. At $195, expect a lightweight construction, fine for layering but not a standalone insulating layer.
Is the price fair?
Good value for the category. Herringbone twill is a step above basic cotton shirts, and $195 is reasonable for a brand-name overshirt with solid seaming.
Best for
Men who layer casually and want one piece that works over t-shirts in spring or as a lightweight third layer in colder months.
Care
Machine wash warm, line dry to preserve the weave; a warm iron will refresh the twill texture.
Fit check: James Perse
True to sizeOwners report James Perse's numeric sizing (0=XS up to 5=XXL) runs true to size, with a deliberately relaxed, California-casual cut rather than a slim one.
Reviewers and sizing guides agree the numbered sizing maps predictably to standard sizes and stays consistent across tees, tanks, long sleeves, and sweats — one long-term owner wears the same size 1 across every James Perse product she owns. The caveat owners flag is that the house cut is intentionally roomy: tees and sweats read slightly relaxed at your true size, so people wanting a trim fit sometimes size down, while button-ups and polos can wear looser than the marked size suggests. On the women's side, fitted jersey pieces are the exception — reviewers note the skinny and fitted styles run small, and pants are cut long.
Sizing advice: Take your usual size converted to the number scale (0=XS, 2=M, 3=L); size down only if you want a trim fit in the relaxed tees and sweats, and size up in fitted jersey styles.
Per owner & reviewer reports: James Perse Sizing Guide — Mensflair · James Perse T-Shirt Review — New Inspired · Does James Perse Run Big or Small? — Tellar
What owners report about James Perse button-ups
Third-party coverage of this brand's woven shirts is thin — most owner discussion centers on its knits, and one brand review notes the polos are considered its best item. Where buyers review the shirts directly, reports split: some praise the linen shirts as soft, well made and well colored, while others report looser-than-expected fit and thin materials they consider poor value at the price. Longtime forum owners advise that the US-made pieces hold up better than the imported ones.
- Strengths
- The linen shirts draw specific owner praise for softness, make quality and color.
- Watch out for
- Reports of thin fabric relative to price and looser-than-expected fit, with forum posters flagging the imported (non-US-made) production as the weaker buy.
- Sizing
- Buyers report the shirts fit looser than the marked size suggests, so consider sizing down if you want a trimmer fit.
About James Perse's button-ups line as a whole. Sources: James Perse Reviews — Trustpilot (jamesperse.co.uk) · James Perse — Styleforum · James Perse Review — Honest Brand Reviews
